| 27/08/2025 |  League Cup · 2e tour |  Grimsby Town(E) | 2–2 | Nul |
| 17/03/1948 |  First Division · Journée 31 | Grimsby Town(E) | 1–1 | Nul |
| 11/10/1947 | First Division · Journée 12 | Grimsby Town(D) | 3–4 | Defaite |
| 28/12/1946 | First Division · Journée 24 | Grimsby Town(E) | 0–0 | Nul |
| 31/08/1946 | First Division · Journée 1 | Grimsby Town(D) | 2–1 | Victoire |
| 14/01/1939 | First Division · Journée 24 | Grimsby Town(D) | 3–1 | Victoire |
| 10/09/1938 | First Division · Journée 5 | Grimsby Town(E) | 0–1 | Defaite |
| 20/03/1937 | First Division · Journée 34 | Grimsby Town(D) | 1–1 | Nul |
| 14/11/1936 | First Division · Journée 15 | Grimsby Town(E) | 2–6 | Defaite |
| 26/12/1933 | Second Division · Matchday 22 | Grimsby Town(E) | 3–7 | Defaite |
| 25/12/1933 | Second Division · Matchday 21 | Grimsby Town(D) | 1–3 | Defaite |
| 31/01/1933 | Second Division · Matchday 26 | Grimsby Town(E) | 1–1 | Nul |
| 17/09/1932 | Second Division · Matchday 06 | Grimsby Town(D) | 1–1 | Nul |
| 31/01/1931 | First Division · Journée 27 | Grimsby Town(E) | 1–2 | Defaite |
| 24/01/1931 |  FA Cup · 4th Round | Grimsby Town(E) | 0–1 | Defaite |
| 27/09/1930 | First Division · Journée 8 | Grimsby Town(D) | 0–2 | Defaite |
| 15/02/1930 | First Division · Journée 29 | Grimsby Town(E) | 2–2 | Nul |
| 12/10/1929 | First Division · Journée 10 | Grimsby Town(D) | 2–5 | Defaite |
| 06/01/1906 | Second Division · Matchday 21 | Grimsby Town(D) | 5–0 | Victoire |
| 09/09/1905 | Second Division · Matchday 03 | Grimsby Town(E) | 1–0 | Victoire |
| 18/03/1905 | Second Division · Matchday 27 | Grimsby Town(D) | 2–1 | Victoire |
| 19/11/1904 | Second Division · Matchday 11 | Grimsby Town(E) | 1–0 | Victoire |
| 12/04/1904 | Second Division · Matchday 30 | Grimsby Town(E) | 1–3 | Defaite |
| 26/03/1904 | Second Division · Matchday 24 | Grimsby Town(D) | 2–0 | Victoire |
| 13/04/1901 | Second Division · Matchday 33 | Grimsby Town(D) | 1–0 | Victoire |
| 08/12/1900 | Second Division · Matchday 13 | Grimsby Town(E) | 0–2 | Defaite |
| 03/03/1900 | Second Division · Matchday 24 | Grimsby Town(D) | 1–0 | Victoire |
| 26/12/1899 | Second Division · Matchday 15 | Grimsby Town(E) | 7–0 | Victoire |
| 04/03/1899 | Second Division · Matchday 25 | Grimsby Town(E) | 0–3 | Defaite |
| 05/11/1898 | Second Division · Matchday 09 | Grimsby Town(D) | 3–2 | Victoire |
| 02/04/1898 | Second Division · Matchday 26 | Grimsby Town(E) | 3–1 | Victoire |
| 27/11/1897 | Second Division · Matchday 13 | Grimsby Town(D) | 2–1 | Victoire |
| 07/11/1896 | Second Division · Matchday 13 | Grimsby Town(D) | 4–2 | Victoire |
| 19/09/1896 | Second Division · Matchday 05 | Grimsby Town(E) | 0–2 | Defaite |
| 14/03/1896 | Second Division · Matchday 24 | Grimsby Town(E) | 2–4 | Defaite |
| 01/01/1896 | Second Division · Matchday 17 | Grimsby Town(D) | 3–2 | Victoire |
| 23/03/1895 | Second Division · Matchday 23 | Grimsby Town(D) | 2–0 | Victoire |
| 17/11/1894 | Second Division · Matchday 10 | Grimsby Town(E) | 1–2 | Defaite |
| 26/03/1892 | Football Alliance | Grimsby Town(D) | 3–3 | Nul |
| 17/10/1891 | Football Alliance | Grimsby Town(E) | 2–2 | Nul |
| 18/10/1890 | Football Alliance | Grimsby Town(D) | 3–1 | Victoire |
| 13/09/1890 | Football Alliance | Grimsby Town(E) | 1–3 | Defaite |
| 14/04/1890 | Football Alliance | Grimsby Town(D) | 0–1 | Defaite |
| 08/02/1890 | Football Alliance | Grimsby Town(E) | 0–7 | Defaite |
| 04/01/1890 | Football Alliance | Grimsby Town(D) | 4–1 | Victoire |
